Customer Reviews

Read what some of our satisfied insurance customers have to say! If you’d like to provide your feedback, please submit your online review.

  • TM
    Wendy and her staff are friendly, professional, and eager to please.

    “Switched to Deibler when I moved to Carlisle from Mechanicsburg. Wendy and her staff are friendly, professional, and eager to please.”

  • CC
    This is the best insurance broker for business and personal needs.

    “This is the best insurance broker for business and personal needs. Deb McClain provides great customer service–speedy turn-arounds, answers all my questions, and looks out for my best interest without pressuring. I wish I knew of this place years ago.”

  • NW
    Wendy and her team do fantastic work...

    “Wendy and her team do fantastic work and allow me to have peace of mind that we are protected.”

  • SM
    Their rates are extremely competitive!

    “Wendy Deibler and her fantastic team are very knowledgeable, professional and helpful. Their rates are extremely competitive!”

  •  Alan Duxbury
    So if you want a honest, ethical team...

    “For 15 years now Deibler (and Erie) have been handling all our insurance needs. Wendy and her staff are almost religious about ensuring that we have had the right insurance for all of our business and personal needs, and made sure that we were completely aware of the costs, benefits, limitations, and all of the trivia which takes a devotion to detail, rather than just a “Sign here”.

    Perhaps the best example of Erie’s performance was when a late season hailstorm passed over Carlisle, causing huge amounts of damage. Within a day, Erie had a crisis team in town, and appraisals were being performed. We had a claim for repainting the front and one side of our property, and without any prompting from us, the appraiser climbed onto the roof and came down again showing us the damage to the shingles, telling us that the hail had taken 15 years off the life of the roof, and that Erie would therefore replace it.

    So if you want a honest, ethical team, then Wendy Deibler, her staff, and Erie Insurance, in my opinion cannot be bettered.”

  • Karen Trynoski
    5 stars!!!
  • Harry Young
    ...got us great rates on home and auto!

    “Deb was extremely helpful, professional, and a delight to work with! She made shopping for insurance easy and personal, and got us great rates on home and auto!”

  • MaryLou Elwood
    Five Stars!
  • Tammy Morrow Book
    5 stars!
  • Gabrielle Chidester
    Wendy was knowledgeable and extremely helpful.

    “Wendy was knowledgeable and extremely helpful with helping us navigate the new health insurance world. Thank you so much for making it easy!”